Hispanic L.A.EnglishAZ proposal would deny...

AZ proposal would deny citizenship to US-born children of undocumented immigrants

An Associated Press article on June 15 reported the move by Republican State Senator Russell Pearce, the man behind SB 1070, to attempt to bar the state from providing birth certificates for children who’s parents cannot provide proof of citizenship or legal residency.

Current national policy, since citizenship is a purely federal issue, is that anyone born in the United States is automatically a citizen. While this policy is a rarity on the international stage, many argue it has made America into what it is today.

According to AP, legal scholars scoff at the idea of such a proposition passing legal scrutiny as it blatantly counteracts the 14th Amendment.

Pearce, however, argues that the intent of the 14th Amendment was to grant citizenship to newly emancipated African Americans, not to invite immigrants to have children on American soil. State Representative John Kavanagh of suburban Phoenix agrees, claiming that states must now take action into their own hands because «federal inaction is unacceptable.» Rand Paul, Kentucky Republican Congressman and Tea Party figure has voiced similar support.

This movement presents an interesting phenomenon: conservatives urging for a loose interpretation of the Constitution; basing their argument on what they think is the spirit, rather than the letter, of the law.

Lee también:   Unacceptable: DOJ secretly pursued records of journalists and members of Congress

This is against the traditional stance of Conservative legal philosophy. For example, John McGinnis, a conservative law professor at Northwestern University, said Pearce’s interpretation is «just completely wrong.»

Conservative justices have in the past been defined by their strict adherence to the written word of the Constitution, so their support for such a radical departure is in question.

What is more concerning is the fact that such a sentiment can be taken seriously in a country where one of our founding tenets is allowing children to have the opportunity that their parents lacked.

This fundamental American value is expressed in the Reconstruction Amendments (the Amendments to the US Constitution immediately following the Civil War) better than any other place. While it may have been used by some illegal immigrants as a tool to avoid prosecution and deportation, the 14th Amendment represents a distinct attempt to give children unlimited opportunity. The public school system and other social social programs were founded under the same spirit.

If America allows such an important part of it’s creed to slip away, the result would be a transformation to an entirely different national tone. The result would be unrecognizable as America of today.

Uri Lerner
Uri Lerner has a Master Degree in Political Science from American University in Washington and is a graduate of UC San Diego with a bachelor's in political science. He is a Senior Research Associate at Hanover Research Council in Washington, D.C.


  1. It is very common to hear that is very rare to find citizenship based only on the birth fact. That is not true. The vast majority of LatinAmerican constituion gives that right to people born in their countries. So, we are land of immigrants. Stop the lie. Pass on the word. As part of the Western Hemisphere is openly spread out that right.

Responder a Julio Benitez Cancelar respuesta

Suscríbete a nuestro newsletter

Recibe una revista semanal con lo más nuevo de HispanicLA y con los artículos que hicieron historia.

En portada

Inversión extranjera y retos en América Latina

La economía de la inversión directa extranjera crea oportunidades para las personas pero se contrapone a la economía financiarista, planteando desafíos éticos y de responsabilidad social. Se limitan los mercados internos al mismo tiempo que se suman los retos de la transición energética de los recursos renovables y sobre todo no renovables.

Lo más reciente


Los 5 temas más buscados